My wife: This is a beautiful dark brown color boots. I am a size 5-5.5 on flats and usually a size 6 on boots and booties (giving room for socks). Before I had bought a size 6 Sofft Anniston Knee High Boots and had to return it coz it was a very tight fit without socks. So when I ordered the Atmore Whiskey boots I got a size 6.5 and this fit just right with thin socks, I wouldn’t use thick socks on this coz it would be too tight. It’s a lighter boots compared to my Born boots, though it might need a little breaking in, but it’s comfortable and cute enough that I plan on keeping it. You can wear it with slightly thin pants or with a dress as shown in my pictures. Only reason I gave it a 4 star is because it had a scratch on one of the boots already and because it’s a dark color boots it’s a pretty obvious scratch. But overall I am happy with it and bought it for a good price too.